Optimizing Order Accuracy: The Long-Term Impact of eCommerce Fulfillment SLAs

Share this post
Postal warehouse employees checking order fulfillment accuracy
Scott Riddle - ShipNetwork
Scott Riddle
Get expert shipping advice delivered straight to your inbox.
Share this post

Precision in Fulfillment: The Power of Order Accuracy

warehouse fulfillment order accuracy scanning

Order accuracy, in the context of pick, pack, and ship fulfillment, refers to the degree to which the items selected, packed, and shipped in an order match the customer's intended purchase. It measures the precision and correctness of the fulfillment process, ensuring that the customer receives the correct items in the right quantities and conditions.

Order accuracy encompasses several aspects of the fulfillment process:

Picking Accuracy

This relates to the accuracy of selecting the correct items from the inventory. It involves accurately identifying the products, variants (such as size or color), and quantities specified in the customer's order.

Packing Accuracy

This refers to the correct packaging of the picked items. It includes verifying that the items are properly packed, protected, and labeled according to the order specifications, ensuring they are ready for shipping.

Shipping Accuracy

This focuses on ensuring that the correct packages are dispatched to the designated customer addresses. It involves accurate labeling, correct carrier selection, and timely delivery to the right destinations.

The Price of Mistakes: Exploring the Impact of Order Accuracy

Maintaining high order accuracy is crucial for customer satisfaction, as inaccuracies can lead to frustrated customers, returns, additional costs, and damage the company's reputation. It is particularly important in e-commerce and retail, where customers rely on accurate fulfillment to receive the products they desire in a timely manner.

To achieve high order accuracy, businesses often employ various strategies such as employing effective inventory management systems, implementing barcode or RFID scanning technologies, utilizing quality control measures, providing adequate staff training, and establishing rigorous quality assurance processes throughout the fulfillment operations. Regular auditing and monitoring of order accuracy metrics allow businesses to identify areas for improvement and take corrective actions when necessary.

When comparing the impact of a 99.9% order accuracy service level agreement (SLA) offered by "3PL A" with a 98% order accuracy provided by "3PL B" in the long term, there are several factors to consider:

Customer Satisfaction

A higher order accuracy rate, such as 99.9%, generally leads to improved customer satisfaction. Customers are more likely to receive the correct items they ordered, reducing the chances of disappointment or frustration. This can result in positive word-of-mouth, repeat business, and customer loyalty. On the other hand, a 98% order accuracy rate may result in a higher likelihood of order errors, potentially leading to customer dissatisfaction and negative reviews.

Return Rates

A higher order accuracy rate often correlates with lower return rates. When customers receive the correct items, there is less need for returns and exchanges, reducing the associated costs for both the customer and the fulfillment provider. A 99.9% order accuracy SLA is likely to contribute to lower return rates compared to a 98% accuracy rate.

Reputation & Brand Image

A consistently high order accuracy rate can positively impact a brand’s reputation and brand image. Customers perceive accuracy as a sign of reliability, professionalism, and trustworthiness. This can lead to a competitive advantage for a brand using 3PLA over 3PL B in terms of attracting new customers and securing repeat business.

Operational Efficiency

Achieving a higher order accuracy rate often requires implementing robust quality control measures, efficient inventory management systems, and training programs for staff. These operational improvements can optimize the fulfillment process, reduce errors, and streamline overall operations. Maintaining a 99.9% accuracy rate requires additional investment in technology and training, which can be difficult for many 3PLs to do.

Cost Considerations

A higher order accuracy SLA, such as 99.9%, involves:

  • Higher upfront costs for implementing sophisticated quality control systems
  • Employing skilled staff
  • Investing in advanced technologies

However, over time, the cost of errors, returns, and customer dissatisfaction associated with a lower accuracy rate proves to be a worthwhile investment. It is crucial to evaluate the overall impact on profitability and customer lifetime value when comparing the cost-effectiveness of working with 3PLs who uphold different accuracy levels.

Breaking Down the Numbers: Why 99.9% Order Accuracy Makes a Difference

Let’s take a deeper dive into a real-world application comparing 3PL A with a 99.9% order accuracy and 3PL B with a 98% order accuracy:

At first glance, one might think that the two SLAs are quite similar. However, when we examine the implications for eCommerce retailers, even a slight difference can make a big deal. Consider a mid-sized company that ships around 1000 orders per day, averaging about 20,000 orders per month.

With a 99.9% order accuracy rate from "3PL #1," the retailer can expect to encounter only 1 failure per day or approximately 20 failures per month. This means they would have 19,980 shipments that are error-free and delivered correctly, while only 20 shipments would have some sort of issue.

In contrast, if the retailer were to opt for 3PL B with a 98% order accuracy rate, they would experience around 20 errors per day or approximately 400 shipments per month that have some form of mistake or problem.

When you consider these numbers, the impact becomes apparent. The difference between 20 shipments with errors and 400 shipments with errors can be substantial in terms of customer satisfaction, operational costs, and brand reputation.

Customers receiving inaccurate orders may result in dissatisfaction, potential returns, negative reviews, and ultimately damage to the retailer's reputation. Additionally, processing returns and resolving issues can be time-consuming and costly for the retailer.

Furthermore, a higher rate of errors places a heavier burden on customer service and support teams, who must handle inquiries, complaints and rectify the mistakes. This can impact the overall efficiency and productivity of the retailer's operations.

The accuracy of order fulfillment is a critical factor in eCommerce success. Even slight variations in order accuracy rates, as exemplified by the comparison between 3PL A and 3PL B, can have a significant impact on customer satisfaction, return rates, brand reputation, and overall operational costs.


For eCommerce retailers, choosing a 99.9% order accuracy SLA over a 98% SLA is far from insignificant. The difference in the number of errors experienced daily and monthly can influence customer satisfaction, operational efficiency, and the retailer's standing in a competitive market.

Prioritizing a higher order accuracy rate, retailers can enhance customer experiences, reduce return rates, and position themselves as trusted brands. By selecting a reliable 3PL with a strong commitment to order accuracy, eCommerce businesses can ensure smoother operations and drive long-term success in the ever-evolving world of online retail.

Take Advantage of Over
50 Million Packages in Purchasing Power

Request a Quote